Don’t feel like cooking tonight? We’ve all been there.
After a long day at work, the last thing you want to do is spend hours in the kitchen.
That’s where ordering a pizza comes in. There’s something magical about a hot pizza showing up at your doorstep, ready to be devoured by the whole family.
If you’re a fan of Papa John’s pizzas, you’re in luck. We’ve taken the liberty of ranking some of their most popular menu items to help you make the best choice for your next pizza night.
Now, keep in mind that we won’t be ranking every single item on the Papa John’s menu. Instead, we’ll focus on a select few that truly stand out.
9. Jalapeño Popper Rolls
Looking for a side to accompany your pizza? Papa John’s offers a surprising variety of options. Among them, the Jalapeño Popper Rolls stand out. These rolls pack a punch and are not for the faint of heart. Filled with cream cheese and jalapeños, they offer a spicy kick that’s bound to satisfy those who enjoy a bit of heat. While they may not be for everyone, if you’re a fan of spicy snacks, these rolls are definitely worth a try.
8. Cheesesticks
When you combine cheese and bread, you know you’re in for something delicious. Papa John’s Cheesesticks are a testament to that. With a soft, garlic-infused bread base covered in gooey cheese, they are a simple yet satisfying treat. While they may seem like something you could easily make at home, sometimes you just want the convenience of having them delivered to your door. Don’t forget to dip them in marinara sauce for an extra burst of flavor.
7. Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Papa John’s offers a variety of pizzas, and the Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza stands out from the crowd. Instead of traditional pizza sauce, this pizza features a fiery buffalo sauce as its base. Topped with onions, cheese, bacon, and chicken, it delivers a tangy and slightly spicy flavor profile. While the chicken may not always be the most exciting part, the pizza as a whole is a unique and enjoyable experience. If you’re a fan of buffalo sauce, this one is worth a try.
6. Zesty Italian Trio Pizza
For those seeking a pizza with a zing, the Zesty Italian Trio Pizza is a top choice. This flavorful pie features Italian sausage, pepperoni, and salami, making it a meat lover’s dream. But what sets it apart is the addition of banana peppers, which add a delightful acidity to balance out the richness. With a sprinkle of Italian seasoning, this pizza offers a satisfying twist on the classic flavors you love.
5. Garden Fresh Pizza
Amidst the heavier options on the menu, the Garden Fresh Pizza provides a refreshing and healthier alternative. Packed with a variety of veggies, including onions, olives, mushrooms, tomatoes, and green peppers, it delivers a vibrant and satisfying experience. The generous helping of cheese adds a creamy richness, complementing the freshness of the vegetables. Whether you’re a vegetarian or simply looking to incorporate more veggies into your meal, this pizza is a delightful choice.
4. Garlic Knots
The combination of bread and garlic is simply irresistible, and Papa John’s Garlic Knots are a testament to that fact. These soft, garlic-infused knots of bread are a true delight. The ample amount of garlic elevates the flavor profile, turning an ordinary bread roll into something special. Topped with Parmesan cheese, they are perfect for dipping into a tangy sauce. Don’t miss out on the dipping sauce—it adds a necessary burst of flavor.
3. Cinnamon Pull Aparts
When it comes to desserts, Papa John’s offers a refreshing change with their Cinnamon Pull Aparts. This sweet treat features bite-sized pieces of cinnamon roll that can be pulled apart and enjoyed individually. Topped with cinnamon crumbles and drizzled with sweet cream cheese icing, these pull aparts offer a lighter, yet still indulgent, dessert option. If you’re craving something sweet that’s not overwhelmingly rich, these cinnamon delights are a perfect choice.
2. Italian Papadia
While not a traditional Italian treat, the Italian Papadia at Papa John’s is a mouthwatering creation. Featuring banana peppers, this Papadia variety adds a zing that complements the hearty combination of salami, Italian sausage, and cheese. What makes it even more interesting is the addition of Alfredo sauce, providing a creamy twist that enhances the overall flavor. If you’re seeking a filling and flavorful option, the Italian Papadia won’t disappoint.
1. Pepperoni Pizza
When it comes to classic favorites, Papa John’s Pepperoni Pizza takes the crown. This all-time favorite embodies the essence of American pizza delivery. With its perfectly melted cheese, crispy pepperoni, and that irresistible cheese pull, it’s a slice of pizza heaven. The abundance of pepperoni ensures that every bite is packed with flavor. While it may not be the most adventurous choice, sometimes sticking with the classic is the way to go.
Comparing Papa John’s to other Pizza Chains
There are a few aspects that some people may appreciate about Papa John’s compared to Pizza Hut, California Pizza Kitchen (CPK), and Domino’s:
Quality Ingredients
Papa John’s prides itself on using high-quality ingredients in their pizzas. They claim to use fresh, never-frozen dough, vine-ripened tomatoes, and real mozzarella cheese. This commitment to quality ingredients can contribute to the overall taste and enjoyment of the pizza.
Signature Sauce
Papa John’s is known for its signature pizza sauce, which has a tangy and slightly sweet flavor. Some people find this sauce to be a standout element that sets Papa John’s pizzas apart from others.
Garlic Butter Sauce
Papa John’s offers a garlic butter dipping sauce that is loved by many customers. This sauce adds an extra layer of flavor and is often a popular addition to their pizzas, breadsticks, or other side items.