Carlo’s Bakery Prices: How much is Carlo’s Bakery?

✅ Verified & Reviewed 🕒 7-8 minutes read.

Is there anything more enjoyable to eat than a scrumptious cake from Carlo’s Bakery? Perhaps, perhaps not but we all agree that the bakery is among the best places to satisfy your cravings for the best cakes, pastries and cookies! Below are the latest Carlo’s Bakery menu prices.


Popular Items

Rainbow Slice$8.95
Red Velvet Slice$8.95


6" Vanilla Confetti Cake$38.62
6" Chocolate Fudge Cake$39.36
6" Strawberry Cheesecake$45.09
6" Rainbow Cake$47.45
6" Black and White Cake$47.45
6" Rainbow Fudge Cake$47.22
6" Red Velvet Cake$46.10
10" Vanilla Confetti Cake$96.36
6" Cannoli Cake$43.59
6" Carrot Cake$45.23
6" Cookies and Cream Cake$39.95
10" Black and White Cake$96.36
6” Americana Cake$39.95
10" Chocolate Fudge Cake$96.36
10" Rainbow Cake$113.98


Classic Cannoli$5.90
Traditional Lobster Tail$6.82
Chocolate-Dipped Cannoli$6.99
Fruit Danish$7.78
Apple Pastry Pocket$7.78
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cannoli$7.45
Creme Brulee Pastry Pocket$7.78
Classic Birthday Cake Cannoli$6.69
Hazelnut Pastry Pocket$7.78
Cherry Cheese Pastry Pocket$7.78

Cake Slices

Chocolate Fudge Slice$8.95
Carrot Cake Slice$9.63
Chocolate Fudge Cake Slice$9.75
Rainbow Fudge Slice$8.95
Rainbow Cake Slice$9.81
Vanilla Confetti Slice$8.95
Vanilla Confetti Cake Slice$9.81
Red Velvet Cake Slice$9.81
Rainbow Strawberry Cake Slice$9.79
Cookies and Cream Slice$9.05
Rainbow Fudge Cake Slice$9.69
Salted Caramel Slice$8.95

Chocolate Dipped Strawberries

Chocolate Dipped Strawberries$26.23


Peanut Butter Cookie$4.17
Black and White Cookie$4.87
Chocolate Chip Cookie$4.30
MandM Cookie$4.29
Vanilla Rainbow Cookie$4.77
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie$4.10

Individual Desserts

Individual Dark Chocolate Mousse$8.88
Individual White Chocolate Mousse$8.88


Buddy's Favorites Box$34.77
5-Pack Cannoli Box$27.95
6-pack Cupcake Box$23.14
4-pack Cake Slice$36.87
6-pack Cake Slice$53.48
6-pack Cookie Box$23.09
4-pack Lobster Tail Box$26.51
4-pack Wedge Bundle$25.70
3-pack Pie Bundle$64.45
12-pack Cupcake Box$46.06

Buddy Bundles

5-Pack Cannoli Bundle$24.95
4-Pack Specialty Lobster Tail Bundle$23.10
Buddy's Favorite Bundle$30.95


8" Apple Crumb Pie$22.70
Pecan Wedge$7.23
8" Pumpkin Pie$22.78
Pumpkin Wedge$7.30
Apple Crumb Wedge$7.24
8" Pecan Pie$22.81


Individual Strawberry Cheesecake$9.16


Vanilla Buttercream Cupcake$3.91
Chocolate Fudge Cupcake$3.91
Vanilla Fudge Cupcake$3.78
Disclaimer: PriceListo gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.
PriceListo Carlo's Bakery prices provided by PriceListo.

About Carlo’s Bakery

Well, of course, there’s the relatively expensive Carlo’s Bakery prices but these are well worth the price. You will agree when you see the long lines snaking out of the bakery and then when you get your first taste of its goodies. You will even say that its cannoli, an Italian classic, is the best you have ever tasted, even better than the ones your Italian grandmother made.


In 1910, Carlo Guastaferro opened Carlo’s Bakery. In 1964, Bartolo “Buddy” Valastro, Sr. purchased the bakery and it has remained a family-run business since then. Today, Buddy Valastro, Jr. manages the chain of bakery with assistance from his sisters, brothers-in-law and other relatives, as well as his friends.  Despite the growth of the business, he has said that it will continue to be in the family for various reasons.

While Cake Boss has established a strong reputation for its wide range of baked goodies, it came to national public attention through the TLC television series, Cake Boss, which premiers on April 2009. The show depicted the staff at the original location in Hoboken, New Jersey creating elaborate customized themed cakes, such as for weddings, anniversaries, and birthdays.

The chain consist of several locations in the United States. These include bakeries in Santa Monica, California, Atlanta, Georgia, Orlando, Florida, and Philadelphia, Pennsylvania as well as in Marlton, Red Bank, Morristown, Wayne, Ridgewood and Westfield, all in New Jersey. There’s even a kiosk booth in Sao Paulo, Brazil, the chain’s first international location.

What They’re Famous For

Carlo’s Bakery is well-known in the United States for its scrumptious cakes, pastries and cookies, among other dessert items. These are all made with excellent quality in terms of taste, texture and flavor, as well as appearance, in mind. Such is the word-class quality of its classic and contemporary baked goods that it has been featured several times in prestigious publications and voted as offering the best cakes in the country.

Why Eat Here

If you’re looking for good-to-the-last-bite baked goodies, then the best place to be is in your nearest Carlo’s Bakery! Here, the prices may be more expensive than your usual neighborhood bakery but the cakes, cookies and pastries are always delicious. There are also dozens of choices so you don’t have to be stuck with the same old baked goodies every day.

If you come on peak hours, which can happen nearly the entire day, you should be prepared to wait in line for more than an hour, no thanks to the long lines snaking out the door. But when you get to the counter, the service is fast, efficient and friendly so your order should be ready in 5 minutes or so.

As soon as you enter, you will feel like a child in a toy store – row upon row of cannoli, cakes and cookies, as well as pastries, are displayed on the large cases. There’s at least one baked goodie for every preference, especially if you’re into classic Italian desserts like cannoli, biscotti, and tiramisu; Buddy Valastro is proudly of Italian descent.

Start with the cannoli as it’s the bestselling item on Carlo’s Bakery menu. The classic Italian treat comes in a generous size, about two to three bites, as well as served with a crispy and firm shell and its filling is rich, creamy and sweet with chocolate chips mixed in.

Then there’s the tiramisu, a dessert item that’s so beautiful to the eyes that you may not want to eat it. These are made as individual-sized cakes bordered with ladyfingers and layered with a light cream filling, ladyfingers, and cocoa powder. You may want to enjoy it with a cup of espresso but it isn’t too sweet that you can’t eat it as it is.

Don’t forget to try the lobster tail, an iconic Carlo’s Bakery treat with a recipe that goes back to the 1900s when its original owner opened it. These pastries are shaped like lobster tails, filled with scrumptious filling, and topped with powdered sugar that complements their crunchy crust.

And then there’s the rainbow cake, a beautiful creation that immediately catches your attention because of its multi-colored appearance. The cake itself is so delicious that the creamy icing just seems like, well, icing on the cake.

There are also more than a dozen choices in cookies, such as cashew cookies, sugar cookies, and butter cookies, as well as brownies with and without nuts.  Be sure to try the signature Cannoli Donut, a must-have combo of doughnut filled with cannoli cream and topped with cannoli shells and cinnamon glaze.

Beyond the cakes, the obvious camaraderie between the staff members makes the wait worthwhile. Customers feel that, indeed, they are part of a family business.

To learn more about Carlo’s Bakery or to find a location near you, visit their website at

Carlo’s Bakery Social Media

Carlo’s Bakery FAQ

How much is Carlo's Bakery's Traditional Lobster Tail?

Traditional Lobster Tail – $6.53

How much is a Rainbow Chocolate Fudge Cake Slice at Carlo's Bakery?

Rainbow Chocolate Fudge Cake Slice – $9.20

How much are Chocolate Fudge Cake Slice at Carlo's Bakery?

Chocolate Fudge Cake Slice – $9.20

How much does a Carlo's Bakery's Peanut Butter Cookie Cost?

Peanut Butter Cookie – $4.07

Carlo’s Bakery Promos 2024